Virginia Governor's Cup
The Competition
Preliminary Round
Over the course of three days, each wine is tasted by 6 judges. This is a single-blind tasting, meaning that judges only know the grape or category of a wine, but the vintage, winery and name are hidden behind coded-glasses.
Finally, individual judges' scores of a wine are averaged into one score after the lowest score is dropped.
Final Round
Over the course of 3 days, 12 judges assess the highest ranking wines from the preliminary round. Unlike the preliminary round, each judge samples all of the Final Round wines.
Each wine in the Final Round receives a final average score after lowest is dropped. The 12 wines with the highest average score are identified as the "Governor's Cup Case."
The wine with the highest overall score is the Governor's Cup Winner.
Judging Criteria
Judges will use the 100 point scale, as used by Wine Spectator, Wine Advocate, Wine Enthusiast, Wine & Spirits, and many others, to rate the most outstanding wines Virginia has to offer.
Tasting Notes
Our esteemed judges assemble tasting notes for each wine commenting on:
- Appearance Clear or dull, color, intensity, any other visual observations
- Aroma Descriptors as to clean or faulty aromatics, fruit, floral, vegetal, spice, oak, chemical, animal, and intensity
- Flavor Character of the alcohol, acidity, body, tannin, oak, fruit, floral, vegetal, spice, oak, chemical, animal, and intensity
- Overall Quality
- Commercial Suitability
Rating Scale
The numerical rating will be used to determine medal winners and advancement to subsequent round.
The Awards
Once the judging is complete, the average wine score will be used to determine if it qualifies for a medal, and the highest 12 ranking red and white wines will become the Governor's Cup Case.
-
Gold
Outstanding/Classic
90-100 points -
Silver
Very Good
85-89 points -
Bronze
Good
80-84 points
Best in Show Cider
Beginning in 2021, Virginia cider is judged in its own category. Judges are selected based on their passion, experience, and understanding of the cider category. Each cider is scored using a 100 point scale. After tasting through all the entries, the top six scoring ciders were identified. The judges then retasted (blind) and ranked their favorites from 1-6. The highest-rated cider will win the Best in Show Cider award.
The Judges
Meet this year's judges; a world-class panel with decades of experience.
Judge Categories
John Brecher
Matthew Brown
Institute of Masters of Wine which, like the WSET, is based in London. Matthew’s passion for food, wine, and unforgettable experiences has taken him around the world, adding the benefit of a global perspective to his work as a business and marketing consultant in the wine trade.
Nadine Brown
Claudia Chamberlain
Sarita Cheaves
As a wine professional dedicated to storytelling, Sarita explores diverse wines and experiments with food. Whether creating vivid recipes, pairing food with a wide range of wines, or interviewing winemakers or chefs, Sarita is committed to sharing new experiences and stories with the VineMeUp Media and The Swirl Suite Podcast communities. She has served as a judge for the Maryland Governor’s Cup Wine Competition.
Quynh Cohen
Emmanuel Dabney
Maria Denton
David Denton
Justin Ferguson
Lindsey Fern
Dorothy Gaiter
Dottie and John are well-known from television appearances and as creators of the annual international “Open That Bottle Night” celebration of wine, family and friendship. In 2020, they donated their papers to the UC-Davis Warren Winiarski Wine Writers Collection, which also includes the work of Jancis Robinson and Hugh Johnson. André Cold Duck was the first wine Dottie and John shared.
Titus Green
Booth Hardy
Erica Jeter
Frank Morgan - Director of Judging
Judging Director
Cassandra Kessman
Anna Kietzerow
Lance Lemon
In 2020, Lance showcased his entrepreneurial spirit by opening RichWine RVA, an online local delivery service. His return to Richmond began a new chapter, where he immersed himself in the local wine scene. Lance further enriched his wine journey by opening Penny's Wine Shop and Wine Bar in Jackson Ward, Richmond, Virginia, in February 2023. Penny's has earned numerous awards and recognitions since its opening, From Forbes "Forget canceled and delayed flight, plan an end of summer road trip to Richmond instead", to Wine Enthusiast "Top 25 Wine Shops", to Vine Pair "Retailer of the Year", to Top 25 restaurants in Richmond from Richmond Magazine and most recently Richmond's dining all-stars of 2023 from Richmond Times Dispatch.
Working alongside winemakers and brothers Ben Jordan and Tim Jordan at their family farm in Shenandoah, Lance honed his craft. Additionally, he served as a Cellar Assistant at Early Mountain Vineyards in Madison County.
A true advocate for Virginia wine, Lance proudly holds the title of Virginia Wine Ambassador with The Virginia Wine Marketing office. Further demonstrating his commitment to the craft, Lance is making his first wine in collaboration with Reggie Leonard at Common Wealth Crush. They are the first to be part of this exciting inaugural incubator program. Their wine is titled The Parallax Project, which focuses on exploring the juxtaposition between the traditional Vitis Vinifera Grape and the new wave of grape growing in Virginia with Hybrids. Lance's journey in wine is about appreciation and active participation, making his mark on the industry from vine to bottle.
Robert Jones, MS
Jay Youmans, MW
Kryss Speegle, MW
With over a decade at O'Neill, Kryss oversees all aspects of grape sourcing, vineyard operations, and winemaking, while also leading the company's business-to-business sales division. As a member of the executive leadership team, she plays an instrumental role in shaping the company's strategic direction. Prior to her tenure at O'Neill, Kryss held various winemaking roles across Northern California. She also develops and teaches wine studies courses, mentors young professionals, and is passionate about building knowledge and inspiring future talent in the wine industry.
Kryss earned her BA in History from the University of Virginia and MS in Food Science/Enology from the University of California, Davis. She holds a Diploma from the Wine & Spirit Education Trust (WSET) and is a member of the Institute of Masters of Wine. Kryss lives in northern Virginia with her husband and daughter.
Lisa Granik, MW
Joel Butler, MW
A professional wine writer since 1977, Butler has contributed to VINTAGE Magazine, Friends of Wine, The International Wine Cellar, Independent on Sunday, the LA Times, and the Contra Costa Times. He is currently a Contributing Editor for the International Wine Review and publishes the blog The WineKnowLog© on Substack.
His book Divine Vintage: Following the Wine Trail from Genesis to the Modern Age, (2012) was voted Best Wine Book by Gourmand International UK. He has also judged wine competitions worldwide, including in London, Australia, Turkey, and the U.S., and has held roles as a wine educator, buyer, consultant, and importer.
From 2015 to 2023, Butler co-owned World of Wines in Redmond, WA. He is based in Washington State and working on a new book.
Courtney Mailey
Dave McIntyre
Sujata Mehta
Outside of the wine world, Sujata is a graduate of George Mason University, holds a degree in Finance, and works for a large government contractor as a Financial Operations Senior Manager. She is the founder and lead of the DC Women in Finance within her organization and is heavily involved in Inclusion and Diversity Initiatives.
Bethany Morris
Tassie Pippert
Winn Roberton
After a stint of wine study in California, Winn returned to his native Washington, DC to open Michael Mina’s Bourbon Steak DC in 2008. There he works with a world-wide wine list featuring affordable finds up to aged first-growth Bordeaux. With a passion for teaching, Winn looks forward to staff training at Bourbon Steak as well as outside engagements.