Virginia Governor's Cup
The Competition
Preliminary Round
Over the course of three days, each wine is tasted by 6 judges. This is a single-blind tasting, meaning that judges only know the grape or category of a wine, but the vintage, winery and name are hidden behind coded-glasses.
Finally, individual judges' scores of a wine are averaged into one score after the lowest score is dropped.
Final Round
Over the course of 3 days, 12 judges assess the highest ranking wines from the preliminary round. Unlike the preliminary round, each judge samples all of the Final Round wines.
Each wine in the Final Round receives a final average score after lowest is dropped. The 12 wines with the highest average score are identified as the "Governor's Cup Case."
The wine with the highest overall score is the Governor's Cup Winner.
Judging Criteria
Judges will use the 100 point scale, as used by Wine Spectator, Wine Advocate, Wine Enthusiast, Wine & Spirits, and many others, to rate the most outstanding wines Virginia has to offer.
Tasting Notes
Our esteemed judges assemble tasting notes for each wine commenting on:
- Appearance Clear or dull, color, intensity, any other visual observations
- Aroma Descriptors as to clean or faulty aromatics, fruit, floral, vegetal, spice, oak, chemical, animal, and intensity
- Flavor Character of the alcohol, acidity, body, tannin, oak, fruit, floral, vegetal, spice, oak, chemical, animal, and intensity
- Overall Quality
- Commercial Suitability
Rating Scale
The numerical rating will be used to determine medal winners and advancement to subsequent round.
The Awards
Once the judging is complete, the average wine score will be used to determine if it qualifies for a medal, and the highest 12 ranking red and white wines will become the Governor's Cup Case.
-
Gold
Outstanding/Classic
90-100 points -
Silver
Very Good
85-89 points -
Bronze
Good
80-84 points
Cider of the Year
Beginning in 2021, Virginia cider is judged in its own category. Judges are selected based on their passion, experience, and understanding of the cider category. Each cider is scored using a 100 point scale. After tasting through all the entries, the top six scoring ciders were identified. The judges then retasted (blind) and ranked their favorites from 1-6. The highest-rated cider will win the Cider of the Year award.
The Judges
Meet this year's judges; a world-class panel with decades of experience.
Judge Categories
Matthew Brown
Nadine Brown
Sarita Cheaves
As a wine professional dedicated to storytelling, Sarita explores diverse wines and experiments with food to celebrate the richness of culture and community. Whether creating vibrant recipes, pairing food with a wide range of wines, or interviewing winemakers and chefs, she is committed to sharing authentic experiences and amplifying new voices within the world of wine.
In December 2025, The Swirl Suite Podcast concluded after years of inspiring conversation and community-building within the wine and beverage industry. Sarita now continues her storytelling journey through VineMeUp Media and is currently working on her first cookbook, blending her love of flavor, culture, and connection.
Follow Sarita @VineMeUp, and explore her ongoing projects and updates on Instagram, TikTok and Substack.
Quynh Cohen
Quynh began her career in the vineyards of Orange County, VA, and later served as a sommelier at Fiola in Miami before joining one of Florida’s top fine wine import/export firms.
She holds a Diploma in Wine & Management, an Advanced Sommelier Certification from Le Cordon Bleu, and a Wine Culture, Heritage & Tourism Diploma from the Georges Chappaz Institute in Champagne—credentials that inform her commitment to regional wine tourism and cultural storytelling. Actively engaged in Virginia’s winemaking circles, Quynh collaborates with local vintners to inclusively spotlight the artistry and exceptional quality of the region’s wines. Now leading the acclaimed “Art of Wine-fullness” program and the Epicurean Classic at The Homestead, she brings over 20 years of expertise to her mission of honoring Virginia’s winemaking legacy with passion and purpose.
Alicia Cypress
Emmanuel Dabney
Maria Denton
David Denton
Brett Drucker
Rachel Gendreau
Rachel also oversees custom crush collaborations, a program that partners with Virginia’s most skilled vintners to craft bespoke, small-batch wines exclusively for Crush Pad Wines and the hospitality group. These collaborations involve working directly with winemakers to select varietals and guide stylistic direction, ensuring the finished wines express the Commonwealth’s distinctive terroir.
Her vision—rooted in education, craftsmanship, and hospitality—guides everything she does, from developing wine programs to creating memorable dining experiences that celebrate the artistry of food and wine.
Beyond her professional endeavors, Rachel enjoys traveling, trail running, skiing, experimenting in the kitchen, and spending time with her fourteen-year-old twin daughters.
Titus Green
Booth Hardy
Erica Jeter
Frank Morgan - Director of Judging
Judging Director
Cassandra Kessman
Robert Jones, MS
Caroline Hermann, MW
Jay Youmans, MW
Lisa Granik, MW
Dave McIntyre
Sujata Mehta
An extrovert to her core, Sujata has a passion for wine education, teaching, and inclusion. She entered the wine industry in 2020 by holding virtual wine tastings and seminars, and continues to cater to private events and clients. She served as a judge in the prestigious Virginia Governor’s Cup competition in 2024 and 2025, and the Shenandoah Valley Wine Competition in 2024.
Sujata is most excited when showcasing excellent wine at any price, with a special place in her heart for women and BIPOC winemakers. She is integrated with the DMV wine community, leading the DMV Wine Tasting Group, and serving as the CFO of Vin.Vitalité: a non-profit that strives to create pathways, connections, and opportunities for all women in the wine community.
Outside of the wine world, Sujata is a graduate of George Mason University, holds a degree in Finance, a minor in Spanish, and works for a government contractor as a Business Process Architect Senior Manager. She is the founder DC Women in Finance within her organization and is involved in Inclusion and Diversity Initiatives.
Bethany Morris
Tassie Pippert
Erin Scala
In past vintages, Erin worked in New York City at several Michelin star restaurants, notably JoJo, PUBLIC, and The Musket Room, where her wine lists won many awards and accolades. For half a decade she also ran the wine program at storied Fleurie Restaurant, where she built her ultimate dream wine list, including a map of Beaujolais painted in wine.
Named one of Wine Enthusiast’s 40 Under 40 wine professionals to watch, her award winning wine lists have helped shine lights on interesting regions and unique topics, like sustainability, climate change, soil influence, and emerging wine regions. Erin received a James Beard Rhône Rangers Travel Study Grant to study Rhône varieties in California. She competed in the Sommelier Scavenger Hunt to find delicious Pinot Noirs in the Santa Cruz Mountains AVA. Her work in wine has been noted in The Washington Post, Wine Spectator, Garden & Gun, The New York Times, Food & Wine, Wine Enthusiast, and she’s been a judge, speaker, and sommelier at various wine events around the world.
Paul Ting
A committed lifelong learner, Paul holds WSET (Wine & Spirit Education Trust) Level 3 certification and is a Certified Specialist of Wine (CSW). His curiosity extends to other fermented beverages and he is also certified as a Sake Professional, Sake Scholar, Shochu Advisor, and Cider Professional.
Writing and consulting form the backbone of his professional life in wine. He writes regularly about wine and spirits, contributing a column to C-VILLE Weekly since December 2019, while also advising retail shops on programming and selection.
Having lived most of his life in Virginia, Paul is an enthusiastic champion of the state's wine industry. He is honored to have served as a judge for the Monticello Cup, Shenandoah Cup, Homestead Norton Challenge Cup, and Virginia Governor's Cup.
In 2022, he co-founded the Virginia Wine Benefit, a nonprofit dedicated to using the strength of the local wine community to support charitable causes across the Commonwealth. After serving as President of the Board for a year, he continues to serve on its Board of Directors.
Patricia Valas
Neal Wavra
Don Whitaker
Kathy Wiedemann
Doug Zerbst